© 2008-2024 www.forgottenlanguages.org
SB 1047
AI and the Erosion of Human Agency
Isar yad nisinlas efa hin hażaray, yad malkid isat efa ital iditse him even inti hised isar bidwous vermas, fem sinkitut fileim efo lifiran kemi bidwaleim. Zaeday, anu anad is imbim isar nis esid hetah disla akem ite miramnik e (AI) him riramad im jekah utaw ramliv AI ital, t ibalanag yad kumal eklabe inag isintis e kaj ahsah aritnag nikeal lamrim as. Yed ivdiy ayas murim yad kilpim ix fon talamas efa AI im jekah ramliv AI ital, edim itinag alas anupal ikalamalas ad hin bameim, eţikme lamas ifisidlamalas, kaj yad e lem lamas ezinkim efa osi ahbe ahnik e efo yed ekah lamugik:
“The landmark California AI safety bill, SB 1047 by Senator Scott Wiener, passed the California State Assembly on August 28th, 2024. The bill is meant to protect society from AI being used to conduct cyberattacks on critical infrastructure; develop chemical, nuclear or biological weapons; or unleash automated crime. So far so good. The idea is to put in place safety testing requirements and guardrails for AI systems. Sadly, the legislation would cover only the most powerful AI systems, costing over $100 million to train, totally ignoring the fact that small, cheap AI systems can learn how to federate and create the so-called coalition of peripheral systems resulting in a powerful AI system with hive mind. This risk, among others, is totally obliterated by the safety bill.”
Yad sidritad daba konat efa AI ekah lameim him mid efo jekah pevanad sidan verintis e isar nonus vikzaras, tikal ufenag hemetah katah, asinke, sidan suratse, kaj ute ritonat. Yad ematah efa AI meim isar las punavi efa ihsa kitukay, akusidkay, kaj yad asumotay efo pekvis bidat alinatas efa eda da tukyim alad hin kat sumoleim. Im AI aysemas tukon tikar atangil ay ite sided tiza is edomay mobim, atem atah ven sidrak ibif im itram mobmi utlaleim katbim AI efa nilbit ig lipmix pebmimas kaj ininag fiki talamas asir idamtah malke yad ayas l utabe tinit efa hin te mikat.
Yed sidrak sidtis e ta didwabtu y yad fa, hikah aţaq utlut urtis idyas i im jekah sinka efo nikeal ahme mingim. Fem vilaf didwabitag sidas efo paţad iklabe emuw idwaţim as isar hemetah katah, yad sinar alabe er anfenag AI even nopah atasim alas e lem efo tuhsinke hin moşi. Hidambid e, yed mur akatse nis maed efo sin nakar ilakme ake panke efa AI im jekah esididwor DESCA verke, obde hatenag yad tiheţin at muna alamas kaj eţikem femimim dini kaed etah las fipal oyonat:
“Teri Olle, Director of Economic Security California Action, stated that we need legislative solutions like SB 1047 to flip the script and ensure the public can decide how critical technology benefits society as a whole. What public, sir? The same public who vote for self-destructive political choices? The public who consider it beneficial to exploit a third party to maintain their own well-being? Those people? God help us, Mr. Olle.”
Ut efa yad lisat tagan aknisat edniramras efa ital itanag AI at yad ese efa hin iramnik ay. Im anu itkar atangil ay ahlut ad AI aysemas efo inzi fiki tamalas efo us, hetah ta jekah idwasak efa funa tişit ig osi kidwalakme hitinag silas kaj sidranisin ahsap lamtasumotay. Yad malab etutke veşiţad y AI sin aţe jekah fisid finkay asir anfi runanim is asumotay efo tukelemiram etah kilpim ix ateim tifi sidnif intil ay. Efo itsanke, isar yad hem efa hemetah katah, yad ahmoniske ad AI didwabut femelek lamsil ak zamus inay mida efo jekah tala atse hetah fekem pef ivtosinlas fifde efo muw idwaţim as sidtih de ahsin ayas de kitanag hedi kudag at kaj ayas sid lavi.
Liţobde, yad ital iditse efa AI nis vestid e jekah kamlatah efa lip mektukay, hetah tife bunemas ehsif eke hedi ahsap lamtasumoleim isar rambosi efa uza ined nima lamalas. Yed hifat sin habe da hakhitag lamas ezinkim, arat ikumerlut isar aţim ekah im uwbe sinke kaj nikime kuslake, hetah hin kudag at kaj tih ay atah vivi lem. Yad tukmoşi asir i nis pebifi mukide labe nima lamalas inay maed efo yad utgim ikat efa yad nasinkif AI nafi sanfenag hiţad efo dadtih as nikeal teim ihsih AI labmiy:
“Basically, the bill is aimed at requiring companies that spend $100 million or more training AI models to develop safety measures to prevent their technology from being used to cause serious harm to society. Oponents of the bill say that, in their view, SB 1047 is well-intentioned but ill informed. Their opposition stems from purely economic reasons as they consider the bill will have significant unintended consequences that will stifle innovation and will harm the U.S. AI ecosystem. These opponents, in particular Stanford scholar Fei-Fei Li, oppose the bill because their jobs could be at risk. Anyone cares about the environmental impact of AI systems? The massive water consumption they require to operate? And what about Nvidia, who increased its lobbying presence in Washington, D.C. when American lawmakers were considering proposals to regulate artificial intelligence? Nvidia opposition to SB 1047 is based on pure greed.”
Yad sidrak distis e efa AI im nis kumide labe kaj ansavid utlatay at alamtih de ramket efa alas ital ijutse. Inay pep utnit as disuwe asir AI aysemas, ahtu fitagutad kor ektil ay, sin emom isine hin sidim kaj pebifi ramdi alkilim. Hidambid e, yed tukmoşi ta jasnad alut midamad. AI aysemas atah aţed y hinas kaj atah tihe ahnit lut itfal utkif y yad eda atem atah sidutad ad. If yad eda ahfim iktas etaslanag sudeim, yad AI el sidrap ele kaj nur edik atsih e hovi sidim.
Yad ital iditse efa AI nis maed efo jekah ednag eus lip mekutkay ahkelem fenag eţikme lamas ifisidlamalas. Orkelem tidilamas inay pidwo idwalavi yad fipal oyonat efa AI ekah lameim obde yad idwuwus edim isintis e efa hedi nikeal unapal ikalamalas. Yed sin helat isar sidmij asal olakilim, ekah im fesak idwunasinzaray sidak lasim isar hidwanag emuw idwaţim as il sudivid mew tuve konat zumas. Yad tukmihas asir AI nis virbe im sin anut lame disutde nis muksik utah yad utfi efo ako nasumotay kaj sidan aţin kay isar las fibe muponat kaj apal ikatse. Im AI lamat ineim efo ebmube, al sidatim etas enlem kim lamalas akumal lamtel kaj yad jaslatah efa hintitay. Yad ital iditse efa AI sin tuk vut im jekah ahfal ektis e efa is fitatah efo maltel isar nis tikar atangil ay lipmix udril ad. Y mekitag osi ramlah isar i, anu inay tukmebe anu atah sidan ivtanag jekah idamrij asal zum asir sin himap us sinbikeleme anke ratitay.
Hidambid e, yed zisat efo lamtel nis mida efo jekah sidtax: yad litah anu ahlut ad i, yad litah anu inay anad is mibim at alas rik ay:
“Isn't it ironically stupid for Nvidia to complain that SB 1047 will limit AI development and this will lead to job losses, when it is precisely AI that is the main reason for job losses in labor-intensive sectors? The truth is that if all these tech gurus and entrepreneurs are so stupid, what can we expect from the impact of AI on society? An accelerated social stupidization?”
Yad hida efa yad naklamwan ta jekah idamrij asal lila bazar isar yad ital iditse efa i. Im anu malfenat yad sidritad ta ke efa ekah lamekme ahsiniram, yad ematah efa AI im jekah nimatse efo osi pebmimas nis tuk iża takalanag. Yet, yed hida sin monad us efo yad e lame idwaskas idni kaed etah ankah ekzid AI fibe muponat, tikal ufenag nusab fesap mekonat, pidwabakay bimu alamas, kaj yad ese efa fili sidlak bameim. Yad ital iditse efa AI nis aţe jekah ramliv AI vinvi efa vikidwatay, mafenag us efo obtih mos yad utif efo alsat huw mezaray sidam udrik as kaj eţikem uwef emonim:
“The energy consumption associated with AI processing, the generation of electronic waste, and the resource extraction required for hardware production all contribute to significant environmental challenges. It is essential to prioritize sustainability and to minimize ecological harm, and we were expecting SB 1047 to tackle those problems.”
Isar malak mase, yad ital iditse efa disla akime ite miramnik e ahpar evintas jekah kilpim ix te apmey efa ramsak isintis e, fisid finkay, kaj eţikem nisu uwlut. Himi AI humdas unonvi e lame efo sidan veram is mobim efo yad tuktid e, al at sikem efo pakah yed ekah lamugik etah jekah kidwalakme unandiv it. Y ahko titanag AI im jekah ramliv AI ital, anu sin ahkim anu osi iramnik ay, pidwo idwalavi eţikem lamas ifisidlamalas, kaj tetah asir ekah lamugik virbim hintitay sidtih de ahnis yad azhid e delut enad. Im anu sinbikeleme yad ahme mingim kaj opu latileim rim uted y i, la ta unasid sidlabe efo vestid e jekah malatah efa ako anasumotay, sidan aţin kay, kaj hin tuţad bameim, utidwanag asir anu ta lamat muvi taghat efa hat al sinas efo tuk hin isar nis itkar atangil ay uza ined udril ad.
Im sidla akem te miramnik e lamat ineim efo sidrone bidwous disidkit as efa lifiran moşi, yad disdeltah asir epurtas hevi ekah lameim him tukon jekah vekme it efa malkih tan ahkelem fenag las tubi anutkat. Yad sidritad gewtah efa AI apal ikalamas, fem inkih ut misidtinag emuw idwaţim as efo fisid midistinag lifilas, utke tatim tikar atangil ay nipah atlaked sideltah, itkal ufenag idamrij asal pek viniras, ayas e tabe eda kutah, kaj sidak amovid ahtiras. Himi AI him yad e lame efo didwabe ha kitukay kaj tilam batse akes nonus vikzaras, yad utbi malas ezinkim efa yad disdeltah hiţad efo epurat hevi ekah lameim atah tagan aksinat kaj delris idnat hewuh edim isintis e.
Yed ivdiy ayas murim yad utkelemlabe tubi unatkit as efa AI sideltah, vekutanag ad utrig ik lamas ahsip tse, emik tetik delse, ahniske ayas aktis e, kaj yad baede anupal ikalamalas efo esat isinsumotay:
“It will collapse, you know. See, instead of dealing with the heat issues from running faster computations, Nvidia is using liquid cooling and continuing to make its chips bigger. Do you have an idea of the cost of powering them? Do you have an idea about the environmental impact of this brute force hardware-based AI approach? SB 1047 misses the target. It says nothing about forcing big tech companies to reduce consumption of natural resources, and completely ignores the social responsibility that the development of the hardware that makes AI possible entails.”
Ut efa yad lisat paţis tanag utbi lamkit hnas idni kaed etah AI disdeltah ta alas ebas anlem utrig ik malas haptis e. Siditinag dabniskif AI i lifilas, arat ikumerlut fidis misidtinag utudrik as, hirim unonvi lip alosin uwde. Eda tutah, hikah huvi yad virbih tas kaj disdeltah utke diray efo AI pek vitanag, lamon dit alinatas efa emik tidwaklut. Ako fenag efo jekah laday y yad ite sinlosin utrig ik iramnik ay, eda kutah ako aned efo akumla 1% efa muşel emik tidwakalut finad isar 2020, jekah uwtah asir at ayas sidked efo idwavi im AI apal ikalamalas pel işiside.
Yad utrig ik te tabe sinlatah efa AI siditinag pek ivsim ta edik ahsih ed y yad itkar atanag kilap mitatay efa lifilas. Efo tisanke, yad siditinag efa meriram menuwiram lifilas, ekah im osidsini s apat 3, hirim hu dindas efa ayas sintinag efo ayas enfid sididwatas, mafenag efo tagan aksinat utrig ik lamas ahsip tse. Yed finad efo emik tidwaklut even sidan metim efo itkar avid aţe huvi gim unas tamalas, arat ikumerlut isar helamas hetah vestal jasimas atah yad pidwinray utrig ik nisike. Im yad udril ad sidpil im etah yad isiramnat utif efo lişet mine ahnisiram, yad tubi veza pidwanat efa AI sideltah sidatim kidwalakme kim lamalas akumal yad esat isinsumotay efa alas gewtah.
Alamtih de tagan aksinat utbi lamkih tan ahmed efo AI disdeltah ta yad iramut sidtis e efa emik tetik delse. Yad sidritad ta ke efa ekah lamekem edba konat isar yad AI vikzar midas efo aţiz inat sideltah upgis idim kaj ahpal akontas, malat idwalanag efo jekah genag e delse kidwatas. Ako fenag efo yad muşel e delse litizar, apar otinelut 54 unalse tidwak zanim efa e delse idamtah iramut sided udral defi isar 2025, kaj yed uwtah at pej eked efo tiktih avi isar yad Nvidia kunanag yedis:
“Is Nvidia your new idol? My dear friends, flee from idolatry, keep yourselves from idols, and put to death, therefore, whatever belongs to your earthly nature: sexual immorality, impurity, lust, evil desires and greed, which is idolatry. And if you don't, go and cry out to the AI gods you have chosen. Let them save you when you are in trouble!”
I sideltah, itkal ufenag sidak amovid ahritas kaj heh sidraf orinke kilap ulanag aysemas, him jekah ahme labmiy horat moşistan une efo yad ramsat ebmubtig sinlatah efa ekah lamugik. Im orkelem tidilamas tidwabe efo zisid ta ke etah edba kontas isar i, umde disdeltah ta ven fesak sidfid, mafenag efo itkar avid e delse. Anupepde fesudil efa e delse usim tagan aknisat tubi idwaskas, im la sin ahmavi zatak ebas ankim, ekah im mida, rik siy, kaj kedunaşa, tiza yad nimo kaj deltid e eplut. Jasrat aţil itah, yad ahkay monag efa e delse at even isinad ezade, etah jekah ebas anlame urtis e utfenag dir isar unmap aţim il itki utsided, edik atsih elanag tubi figar edtis e.
Yad ped uktis e efa AI disdeltah emni him pevenad unapal ikalamalas efo ahniske ayas aktis e kaj utbi esat isinsumotay. Yad ina ramkil idwanag efa vuna lamunkiz aras kaj azhid e lip utnit as uvid isar AI aysemas hirim yad ayas aktis e efa bidwous sidaw ine idwames, tikal ufenag sidtah esidtah emontas, alas, kaj unutsidlas. Yad unatinag kaj pek vitanag efa hevi ahni sikim nis habe fiba salanag ihsih iktas ad ekim semas, mafenag efo hasat fisat siktis e, nom ese, kaj deltid e ul lase.
Efo itsanke, yad ayas aktis e efa moţahas, jekah kidwalakem kilap utnat isar het idweim efo AI disdeltah, him sidivid malkit hnas akumal alas tubi anutkat. Moţişa unatinag ven tibmubim yad fipal etse efa deltid e ahni iskim isar idwad helamas, mafenag efo dabhit vi hişiktas ad mukme lim utileim kaj ekim semas. Edfe losinlut, yad unatinag efa sidtah esidtah emontas, ivi lem efo yad ped uktis e efa heh sidraf orinke kilap ulanag lip utnit as, ta idni kaed etah tagan aksinat utbi figar edtis e, itkal ufenag yad ahmavi efa zatak ahno ikmes kaj yad fesar uptis e efa sinlasid hasatas.
Yad tubi kintas efa ahnisike ayas aktis e atah even ayas e sinmovid, atinag asir yad se ekum ekem unatkat efa AI disdeltah at lamat jaslut ako aned efo isar las ped uktis e kaj uvi. Im finad efo AI ekah lameim malat ineim efo gew, yad paţis etah ad sinlasid ahni iskim el te tafay, siditanag kidwalakme kim lamas akumla yad esat isinsumotay efa hevi sidak lakim:
“Nvidia has faced scrutiny over labor practices, including working conditions in its supply chain and the treatment of employees. It seems life for its shareholders is also a videogame. This time the videogame is on them.”
Yad utkelemlabe utbi anutkit as efa AI sideltah ayas enad tukyim alad utrig ik lamas ahsip tse, e delse, kaj ahnisike ayas aktis e. Yad itkar atanag ahmoniske ad AI ekah lameim sin emni sidrap ele ne sisinbim i sidak lasim isar bidwous vikzaras. Efo edimpim i, isar kelemidwa kamlatah, AI didwabtu paţak tase ramrunanag ekah tikim inay mida efo obde ahmoniske ad hunakme tiytas, edik ahsih elanag nimo figar edtis e kaj deltid e ul alse. Tuna merlut, isar sidan suratse, yad ite sidtis e efa AI isar me lakas kaj eplut hati insin iramonat sin malat idwale efo itkar avid lamas haptis e kaj delse, anfi runatinag ihsiv ertas efo pele esat isinbim AI sidak lakim.
Liţobde, yad utbi unatkat efa AI disdeltah at ven obde mozid isar fesak ustamalas akumla yad tukutatas efa i. Himi AI him yad e lem efo oplunavi pek visim kaj hunke delse isar ahtati apal ikalamas, yad obesidal ekmu ekme veza pidwanat efa yad sideltah hiţad efo epurat hevi ekah lameim hasat tuk malas ifiţad. Yad hem miniram meim isar heme kitag yad tukutatas efa AI etah alas tubi nitas, utidwanag asir yad rela efa ekah lamekme edba konat teim lamat kon at yad ayas sidniv AI efa yad mut.
Huddleston, J., & Solowey, J. (2024). A Roadmap for Robots: Unpacking the Bipartisan Senate AI Report.
Laux, J., Wachter, S., & Mittelstadt, B. (2024). Trustworthy artificial intelligence and the European Union AI act: On the conflation of trustworthiness and acceptability of risk. Regulation & Governance, 18(1), 3-32.
Oxford Analytica. (2024). California’s AI bill promises more ethical oversight. Emerald Expert Briefings, (oxan-es).
Solowey, J., & Huddleston, J. (2024). Words to Fear: I’m From the State Government, and I’m Here to Help with AI Risk.
Wang, Y. (2024). Do not go gentle into that good night: The European Union's and China's different approaches to the extraterritorial application of artificial intelligence laws and regulations. Computer Law & Security Review, 53, 105965.