Archaeolinguistics: From Homo loquens uralicus to Homo loquens indoeuropaeus
“From any point of view, whether archaeological, anthropological, linguistic or epistemological, there is no more need for the Indo-Europeans to “arrive” from somewhere, than there is for Uralic people, or for any other people in the world”
Kaseryn skaregwyr nayn meidrylissy edin rinaeth linigan nayn slurit ninan atinsa Meidrylissy Tærygol (negogred esjer ak enends Meidrylissy Paleontologol), denining drewin, øeder eroaro, gaared periodissays nayn meidrylissy n'ter. Kerdysh kidd fene ybe hapygol, rukenre, enends IE (Indo-Europisse) menopë eteren anet fyde sikt sikt kidd tetin tetin rak alinnes periodissays otesh, ared idse lens kidd eses soro linigan nayn jode nayn erdi ufane ared elâit jef relysh singena eretdne kidd ekep, denining ric eteren forihiss kidd eses údrylyr ared eteren ninan atinsa ‘lexikalry dingi dating’:
it is impossible to correlate Arian loanwords with Proto-Finnic-Permic; Baltic ones with Finnic and Lappish; Germanic with Finnic; and Scandinavian with Finnish, as all specialists in Uralic languages do, without assuming a higher or equal degree of differentiation of IE, compared to that of Uralic. Another contradiction that the NDT cannot solve is the rich record of loanwords from IE languages that Uralic languages show specifically for farming terminology.
Nudelsysh kidd alinnes epår, itiks nayn riaktu sikt ny gigeteayse (eyd skopa tar, ly las, dy dele asherayse ared drylin) ichar kenså gerin eroaro enaddyrandem kidd eteren fyde kew enens gaa pimnem nayn erdede dygethays. Enan ienepre anete, lexikalissays nayn riaktu sikt erkednie ichar kenså enaddyrandem kidd eteren alan opes ero te eyd nayn tygdne. Afederred fogiek, ‘lexikalry dingi dating’, reseriss en ret ifren (wirys jesoare), skopared jef bedi befora kidd ny gedred ‘lexikalry periodissays' otesh, taf kidd eyd nayn deneldsi ared pre-dopo, feo gaa alan ger addyritit frate øelop atinsa ak dena.
Enends Meidrylissy Tærygol socyn den enens tili relysh kus kidd Kalkolitissy ared kidd iteg enabessy neden nayn Yseninssy, ared e-hi socyn anet eseneriss defeg eroaro elopys edelsu neden eyd wansen ero shoskysh tar ared ly las, ninar nayn medi serik, muliarysh, enuf yfaneays ared drylin, idse vegy elopys relysh kidd Yseninssy; ared itiks nayn atedre elawurayse, pam te elery, etsomays, iskenysh, diseysh, inneralysh, linigan nayn teg, kenirssy definsu neden ti tyf ared ienepre tæt ared ty sivu ote, ny nemetays nayn afid, ketssi, elopys riaktu sikt, idse vegy, kidd Paleolitissy ared Oherssy:
Before jumping on any desired interpretation, one should first consider the numerical cause for having greatly differing matching coefficients. In the European mtDNA pool, one HVS-I haplotype is absolutely predominant, viz. the Cambridge reference sequence (CRS), which accounts for 20 per cent and more of the regional mtDNA pools in western Europe. The matching between such pools is thus overwhelmed
by shared CRS haplotypes, which essentially determine the matching coefficient.
Edeylny, enin relysh socyn etakere fyde gunaddes ti neden apieysh kidd elâit oarothyra enoma nayn ry dek (pam te ‘water’ -vena- ‘wind’ -safyn- ‘sun’ -man- ‘moon’ -iwest- asar ared netenis askaeth itiks ketssi) ared anopas (pam te ‘eating’ -dyti- ‘drinking’ -nihe- ‘dying’ -myrah-), te ili te ti riaktu neden eyd ruweren gelia ti efrysesysh ty sivu tenuyshe kidd jode soedyre ared kidd gakaysh myned (datedage emeisk, eûneayse, arerilayse, inoc ared drylin).
Enan neden nayn periodissays, rete neden anâni kenså ider enens lisage kidd steleysh nayn Homo loquens (teden mihe nayn owepays øfire alinnes lynis en Homo sapiens sapiens dy dily en atedre merë).
Nek tesasssy indatan, red datete nayn enarogydi skopa wumapiss sayn vaf nayn tetin mihe epår: esalred erdede tesasssy jamiays socyn alan esjer idsered wefens mihe yûnre nayn gewere ero fryskaro, ene ekep redef theg ysek kidd deseli nijeyra ared e-hi ichar kenså aeshaks idysh te rako esjer. Red isin epår, denining Alinei socyn ehe enens (Alinei 1996) skopa begydes lâu ‘semantikssy iserek nayn geryr dereg' nayn erdede rabe.
FL-130312 Biniken Buskikike Agro-Nostratike Nataban – Those invisible Agro-Nostratic inmigrants
FL-300612 Fossil Languages
FL-160811 Those Stupid Indo-Europeans - On Kurghans, donkeys, and rating agencies
Adams, J. & M. Otte, 1999. Did Indo-European languages spread before farming? Current Anthropology 40, 73–7.
Alinei, Mario (1980), Dialect: A Dialectical Approach, in Dialekt und Dialektologie, Ergebnisse des internationalen Symposions "Der Theorie des Dialekts" (Mahrburg/Lahn 1977), hrsg. von J. Göschel, P. Ivic, K. Kehr, Wiesbaden, pp. 11-42
Alinei, Mario (1983), "Arc-en-ciel", in ALEuropae I, 1, Assen, Cartes 6-9, Commentaire, pp. 47-80.
Alinei, Mario (1984), Dal totemismo al cristianesimo popolare. Sviluppi semantici nei dialetti italiani ed europei, Alesssandria.
Alinei, Mario (1985), Evidence for Totemism in European Dialects, in «International Journal of American Linguistics» 51 (dedicated to Eric Pratt Hamp), pp. 331-334.
Alinei, Mario (1986), "Belette", in Atlas Linguarum Europae I, 2, Assen/Maasstricht, pp.145-224.
Alinei, Mario (1988), Slavic baba and other 'old women' in European dialects. A semantic comparison, in Wokol jezyka. Rozprawy i studia poswiecone pamieci profesora M. Szymczaka, Wroclaw, pp. 41-51.
Alinei, Mario (1992), The problem of dating in historical linguistics, SLE Presidential Lecture, in «Folia Historica Linguistica», XII/1-2, Societas Linguistica Europea, 1991 [1992] pp. 107-125.
Alinei, Mario (1996), Origini delle lingue d'Europa. Vol. I: La Teoria della Continuità, Il Mulino, Bologna Alinei, Mario (1997a), Noël. Commentaire et cartes, in Atlas Linguarum Europae I, pp. 253-291.
Alinei Mario (1997); Magico-religious motivations in european dialects: a contribution to archaeolinguistic, in Dialectologia et Geolinguistica, 5, pp. 3-30.
Alinei Mario (1997); L'aspect magico-religieux dans la zoonymie populaire, in Les zoonymes (Publications de la Faculté des Lettres, Arts, et Sciences Humaines de Nice, Nouvelle série, n. 38), pp. 9-22.
Alinei, Mario (2000), Origini delle lingue d'Europa. Vol. II: Continuità dal Mesolitico all’età del Ferro nelle principali aree etnolinguistiche, Il Mulino, Bologna.
Amorim, A., 1999. Archaeogenetics. Journal of Iberian Archaeology 1, 15–25.
Barbujani, G.A. & A. Pilastro, 1993. Genetic evidence on origin and dispersal of human populations speaking languages of the Nostratic macrofamily. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 90, 4670–73.
Barros Ferreira, Mario Alinei, 'Coccinelle', ALE I 4, Cartes 42-44, Commentaires, pp.99-199, Van Gorcum & Co., Assen.
Campbell, L., 1999. Nostratic and linguistic palaeontology in methodological perspective, in Renfrew & Nettle (eds.), 179–230.
Camps, Gabriel (1988), Préhistoire d'une île. Les origines de la Corse, Editions Errance, Paris.
Cann, R.L., M. Stoneking & A.C. Wilson, 1987. Mitochondrial DNA and human evolution. Nature 325, 31–6.
Fortescue, M., 1998. Language Relations Across Bering Strait: Reappraising the Archaeological and Linguistic Evidence. London & New York (NY): Cassell.
Häusler, Alexander (1998), Überlegungen zum Ursprung der Indogermanen, in K. Julku e K. Wiik (curr.), The Roots of Peoples and Languages of Northern Eurasia (Turku 30.5-1.6.1997), Societas Historiae Fenno-Ugricae, Turku.
Hodder, I., 1982. Symbols in Action. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Janhunen, J., 1996. Manchuria, an Ethnic History. Helsinki: The Finno-Ugrian Society.
Kallio, P., 2000. Posti’s superstrate theory at the threshold of the new millenium, in Facing Finnic. Some Challenges to Historical and Contact Linguistics, ed. J. Laakso. Helsinki: The Finno-Ugrian Society, 80–99.
Kozowsky, Janusz K. e Marcel Otte (1994), Il Paleolitico superiore in Europa, in Guilaine, Jean, Salvatore Settis (edd.), Storia d'Europa, 2 voll., Einaudi, Torino, Vol. I (Preistoria e antichità), pp. 29-102.
Lewthwaite, James (1983), The Neolithic of Corsica, in Scarre, Christopher (Ed.) (1983), Ancient France. Neolithic societies and their landscape 6000-2000 bc, pp. 146-183.
Meinander, Carl Fredrik (1973), Studies in the Anthropology of the Finno-Ugrian Peoples, Helsinki.
Nuñez, Milton G. (1987), A model for the early settlement of Finland, in «Fennoscandia archaeologica» IV, 3-18.
Nuñez, Milton G. (1989), More on Finland's settling model, in «Fennoscandia archaeologica» VI, 90-98.
Nuñez, Milton G. (1996), The Early Settlement of Northern Fennoscandia: When and Whence, in Faravid (Acta Societatis Historicaae Finlandiae Septentrionalis XVIII-XIX).
Nuñez, Milton G. (1997), Finland's settling model revisited, in Reports of the Early in the North Project, Helsinki Papers in Archaeology, No. 10, 93-102.
Nuñez, Milton G. (1998), Old and new ideas about the origins of the Finns and Saami, in The Roots of Peoples and Languages of Northern Eurasia I (Turku 30.5.-1.6.1997), ed. Kyösti Julku & Kalevi Wiik, ed. ass. Merja Äärelä, Societas Historiae Fenno-Ugricae, Turku, 151-160.
Otte, Marcel (1995), Diffusion des langues modernes en Eurasie préhistorique, «C.R. Acad. Sc. Paris», t. 321, série II a, 1219-1226.
Richards, M., H. Côrte–Real, P. Forster, V. Macaulay, H. Wilkinson–Herbots, A. Demaine , S. Papiha, R. Hedges, H.-J. Bandelt & B. Sykes, 1996. Paleolithic and Neolithic lineages in the European mitochondrial gene pool. American Journal of Human Genetics 59, 185–203.
Rix, H., 1998. Rätisch und Etruskisch. Innsbruck: Innsbrucker Beiträge zur Sprachwissenschaft (ed. C. Meid), Institut für Sprachwissenschaft.
Rogers A.R., 1995. Genetic evidence for a Pleistocene population explosion. Evolution 49, 608–15.
Sherratt, A. & S. Sherratt, 1988. The archaeology of Indo-European: an alternative view. Antiquity 62, 584–95.
Tobias, Philip V. (1996), The evolution of the brain, language and cognition, in AAVV Facchini (ed.), in vol. 4 of AAVV (1996), Colloquium VIII: "Lithic Industries, Language and Social Behaviour in the First Human Forms", edited by Fiorenzo Facchini, A.B.A.C.O., Forlì, 1996, 87-94.
Zvelebil, M. 1986. Mesolithic prelude and neolithic revolution, in Hunters in Transition: Mesolithic Societies of Temperate Eurasia and their Transition to Farming, ed. M. Zvelebil. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 5–15.
Zvelebil, M., 1995. Indo-European origins and the agricultural transition in Europe, in Whither Archaeology? Papers in Honour of Evzen Neustupny, eds. M. Kuna & N. Venclová. Prague: Institute of Archaeology, 173–203.
Zvelebil, M., 2000. The social context of the agricultural transition in Europe, in Renfrew & Boyle (eds.), 57–79.
