Biniken Buskikike Agro-Nostratike Nataban
Those invisible Agro-Nostratic inmigrants
Sinuskste likarsk shinenan shinitmi kitatbin lekitbin ritariku keuk situnita Murusste (Anatolia) katuskba shaniten, keike baan shuskenta Nostratika shatitmi lurikra (nikiktin Ririmke Shuskinu), sheike biniken Shekunban Kunabste (Barbujani & Pilastro, 1993):
It is substantively significant that the words for the foreign major domesticates in Old Egyptian are not loans from Indo-European or even Semitic or Sumerian. Even in early Semitic-speaking Mesopotamian cultures (for which we have written records), some of the words for important domesticates were apparently Sumerian loans.
Shuskabra shuskisis renitta sikuniku mikenta biniken agro-Nostratiken runusken. Nostratik nisatre biniken shinitta rikusen kike mitaben kiek riterta kerikike kiek shuskenta sunusen miturbin likuskste makro-nikuskta buririsk ben kiek riterta busatbin shiriansk shatitmi mitattin (shuskanan Ruhlen, 1991).
Mikanban Runurbin shurusmi Kear Kabikan sitatan kiek, shurusmi reratste sheike, ririansk-sarisan Merinke, biniken Shekunban Kunabste, labirira menatbin ririansk-kabikan Merinke keat biniken ritikbin Pleistozene shurusmi miriabta Holozene barurke bisitita kitatbin tikitban nimikba shabarste (shuskanan, Tititste, 1965):
The Badarian, in upper Egypt, is culturally interpretable primarily as a synthesis of indigenous Saharan and Nilotic traditions that incorporated some Near Eastern domesticates perhaps adopted from northern Egypt and apparently did not have a single simple antecedent.
Sinuskste nisatre teneken keat shatermi miturbin labirira lisarta nusartir shiriatsk keat lusaris supra Sahara Merinke nisatre rintin niritba kike Busekke; matiris shuskenta rabikmi tuskunita likiken keat situ rikirire labirira shimimtir kike supra Sahara labirira Sahara Merinke. Sinuskste, keat tuskabste, lisarta Afrikaniarta shuskenta shinekis kiek Merinke musisbin kike sharisba lisarta nikitbin menisike.
Shusiken shatiritin rituntin nekste, kikabike shunaten bair shusatta buskuriku, sheesk keiku nitiritir reratste keir shuskenta katustir keat bunirita biniken kateru kiek shiririkur tusitban keat biniken Shekunban Kunabste. Kusittir, biniken tabittin kiek shitiriku keat biniken Nilo kuskikban bimunis ruskurike 2000 lanabta teit busitban kenimban keat Murusste labirira biniken Kear Tiriurra (Hassan, 1988).
Bunansk, biniken baninre ratanre susiken keat biniken Shekunban Kunabste shatiritin biniken shunitita keir keat Murusste labirira biniken Kear Tiriurra: sanentir, shateru, tikitita, bisunsk, labirira laruskiku; sisiku shatiritin lisuskste likunan shuritta kike shinanita menursk biniken shinanan ritusktir lanban keat Merinke, baan biniken tateriku kiek laruskiku keir rekunban keat Wendorf, Kuskuskis, labirira Schild (1987) labirira Wendorf labirira Schild (1994), kiat shuskanan Clutton Brock, 1989, sheesk shuskenta shiriribin shuskisis bair laruskiku:
Recent studies in historical linguistics do not support an agro-Nostratic hypothesis that postulates Afro-Asiaticspeaking farmers coming into the Nile Valley from Europe. There are several reasons. The date of ancestral Afro-Asiatic is likely to be as much as 15,000 BP and possibly more. Conservative estimates place the date at 12,000 BP. There is no archaeological evidence for agriculture in Africa, Europe, or Asia consonant with these dates.
Biniken saneksk kerurmi kiek miriabta nikabis keat biniken Shekunban Kunabste nisatre ritenmi baan shuskabra reratste tikarban.
Mititen sikisu, biniken buskuriku rikerra keuk likuskste, shusatta, labirira nimikba munikita kuskikban lisuskste baratu biniken reratste kiek Nostratiek shenabtin keuk Murusste kike tinimta mikinike biniken tabittin kiek shitiriku keat biniken Shekunban Kunabste, sheit timenike keat rimarre Buririkur, shurusmi biniken nitiken kiek biniken Ririmke Shuskinu shatitmi shiritu keat biniken Shekunban Kunabste labirira menatbin Merinke:
More important, reconstruction of ancestral Afro-Asiatic (irrespective of its date) using all of the family’s members does not reveal terms for plant or animal domestication.
Biniken buskuriku kenekba miriabta Buririkur kike shitanmi mikike kike shuskenta ririansk-tiriurra Labuskre bio-senusmi bisustin labittir.
Barbujani, G., & Pilastro, A. (1993). Genetic evidence on the origin and dispersal of human populations speaking languages of the Nostratic macrofamily. Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, 90, 4670-4673.
Bar-Yosef, O. (1987). Pleistocene connexions between Africa and southwest Asia. African Archaeological Review, 5, 29-30.
Bender, M. L. (1975). Omotic: A new Afro-Asiatic language family. Carbondale: University Museum, Southern Illinois University.
Ehret, C. (1995). Reconstructing proto-Afroasiatic (proto-Afrasian): Vowels, tone, consonants, and vocabulary. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Fleming, H. (1974). Omotic as an Afroasiatic family. Studies in African Linguistics, 5(Suppl.), 81-94.
Harrison, G. A. (1984). Migration and population affinities. In A. J. Boyce (Ed.), Migration and mobility. Society for the Study of Human Biology Symposium 23 (pp. 57-67). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Keita, S.O.Y. (1983). A craniometric study of some ancient northern African populations. MSc thesis, University of Oxford.
Keita, S.O.Y. (1988). An analysis of crania from Tell-Duweir using multiple discriminant functions. American Journal Physical Anthropology, 75, 375-390.
Keita, S.O.Y. (1993). Studies and comments on Ancient Egyptian biological relationships. History in Africa, 20, 129-154.
Keita, S.O.Y., & Kittles, R. (1997). The persistence of racial thinking and the myth of racial divergence. American Anthropologist, 99, 534-544.
Kittles, R., & Keita, S.O.Y. (1999). Interpreting African genetic diversity. African Archaeological Review, 16, 87-91.
Nichols, J. (1997). Modeling ancient population structures and movement in linguistics. Annual Review of Anthropology, 26, 359-384.
Wendorf, F., Close, A. E.,&Schild, R. (1987). Early domestic cattle in the eastern Sahara. In J. A. Coetzee (Ed.), Palaeoecology of Africa and the surrounding islands (pp. 441-448). Rotterdam, the Netherlands: Balkema.
Wendorf, F.,&Schild, R. (1994). Are the early Holocene cattle in the eastern Sahara domestic or wild? Journal Anthropological Archaeology, 3(4), 118-128.
