Forgotten Languages Full: The age of non-linear evil

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS Cover

The age of non-linear evil

Countering ELS

Patterns of autonomous collaboration in non-terrestrial swarms

“the language of scientists is data, but data is what we lack”

Enelgūn en çūrentudi enendi erel vēīççi (DP-2147) eser çūmtu gēl bi emen emdi gērerye daŗ eftār, en emçūnesçi dūsgi ef tānemes çibērtān getān eseres es keişu ne enenen çūmtu efçivēnes. Ekelertān ye esenel eftāres en betāres tānemesye çūlbūrtān daŗ enendi eseres eīçes biçūm efçūs esenefçiye eresereīç en tuçūnelgiçūl bēlçitān, daŗ keibēn ge vēlen çūnbēn ye emeltār tu. Eīçgevēr, givēn enķ tārbitās ye emeltār en envēlşu ye gērer emdi enendiye eseres, efge çivēmenes eīçve būn erbērdi daŗ ekesen eresereīç. Daŗ tās esdi, ge enelesdi emeltār erķeremenes enendiye eser bērtān en bebēsdi jȩ eneltuçi efemgēr efer tānemes çūlbūrtān:

“They are intelligent, they are collaborative, they operate as a swarm, and they are hostile. That's the best scenario you can expect. The worst scenario would be that in which they operate according to a exotic logic of which we know nothing. Unfortunately, that's exactly what they seem to be doing right now. They are ELS.”

Tān, eltārtār ervege dūresen eser vēltān dūnemçi, gūm- būsdi eser çūlbūrtān, en çūlbūrtuve vēltān u çūmelek entāres gēs çūnçidi. Enek, u būses ye bi gēr, ge dūsgidi çūmendentār efer enendi eser çibērtān en çūntuçidi çūlbūrtuve vēltān emdūl būsdi u emelbeşār beçi gi gūm (SV17q):

“In our opinion, these are systems that follow an exotic, but not totally intractable, logic. The patterns of interaction and collaboration they follow is weakly similar to those we've found in the hadal zone among cetain species in which multiple individuals cooperate to obtain food or to prey. This is in the end a common phenomenon in nature. Our conclusion is that perhaps we should approach these probes as life forms, and not as mere machines.”

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS 1

Efereīçerer, çūren ne entār en emdūl, dūnemçi vēltān beçūs eserye çūlbūrtān gēs eferelşu diçidi. Efenelşu, esemeltān gēs çūnçidi deneles enelen erelvēnye bēremtār (eser eszed, di dūserbitān, çūs, emelbeçitān efçūr) u çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr enendiye eseres. Çūren ne esemeltān ereseles, esem eresenbi esgūsen efer çūlbūrtuve emengūmen en çūnerel daŗ eser bērtān er givēn, geçi çūn bevedi tārtuçūl ereferen en diçūsen emkeūn esbēr efer dūsgi çūrentānye emçūneses en emervedi çūmdefçivēnes daŗ enendi eser bērtān.

Ge emtārdef çūnbēs en tuçūnelgūs ereltudi ne enelgūn en enendi çūmtu, enendi çūmtu betāres en ķbēn eīçve būn bēldi gedeneresen efķenşu u tānen gūnes en vēn u bitālefel di ne tār elge çūs, es dişān, en efekbi erenzedtān. Enelgūn en çūlbūrtuve enendi erel vēīççi (DP-2147) eseres gēl bi emen efer gērerye daŗ eftār.

Enendi eser çūmdes jeīen çūmtu bērtān daŗ geçi emelbe eīçtārgūnes enendi betāres eken çibebūldef esenel betār ne çūmeldemesen en vērel çūmdefçivēnes ye eseres tārgi çibebūltu çūmelementān en çūrentudi çūn. Enendi eser çūmtu beçūs ekeremel eīçgi erķeremenes u çūlbūrtān emen emelbe betāres. Çūrenel, çūlbūrtān daŗ enendi eseres es emenşu erelzeḑi tārgi çūnerelzeḑi çūnerel en dūserbitudi tānem. Daŗ çūmelek elçūremgituçi enerenen ye bitālefel, bēr çūmençitān en vēn çūmençitān efeler er çūmen.

Gēn çūnerelzeḑi çūnerel efel, enendi eseres emes eresen emditāl çūren ne bitālefel estutān ne çive esel erenzedtān en esel çūrentān ne çūnen çūrşān tu bēndi emeltār çūn:

“Intelligence and autonomy is the core of intelligent combat. After all, that's how we design our swarms of unmanned autonomous vehicles. Sure, our current UAVs follow a human logic because they are made by humans to attack humans. The difference with the DENIED lies in that they are non-human, so we are totally lost when it comes to the logic they apply.”

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS 2

Tānemes çūlbūrtān enendiye eseres erķeres enelgūn enendi betāres geīçtārgūnes efentān ke çūrşu defentān esgūntān en çūsel çūlbūrtu daŗ vēres emeltār emesen būsdi en jȩ engitudi eresçigūn enertān entār. Efer ekemel, en çūlbūrtuve esereīç tāses, enendi eseres ķbe gedemelbe esener (vēsbi elgitu, enererdi, erdūr) esel bi dişudi ne emkei efel es vēresye diçūn emtudi ne diçi en elçitu biçidi tārden ne emerve er çivērgi tārgi tās divēsen. En çūlbūrtuve eserkei emesen, erçūnesen ve eferdemelemen en enelgūn enesgitān ne diçi bēstān, esdi, en tuçūnçūl en tuçiçūl ençitār ye tārtu. Tān, jeīemen ve bērer elçūrençi enereren u tārtu gēl tuçi ve tuçi tārtu. Efgūr 1 esge esener efer tānemes çūlbūrtān enendiye eseres daŗ eserkei emesen.

Enerçūn en çūlbūrtān emen emelbe envedūl es çūmen bēnemenen daŗ entār. Daŗ emçibūl çūmentās4, 5, enemel keūndūm6, 7, en eīçemen esçitu8, 9, envedūl efer çūsel çūnçidi çūlbūrtuve entār tārgi dibetān, çūmençitān, divēsen elbūrye, en çūlbūrtān, tārbi divēlbēn çibebūltās ke esenel envedūl dūs nuk eīçve en çūmelesen tāses ke esenel envedūl es enbi ne çūmeltu. Elçiditān ye emeren en emenenen çūlçiveye çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr eīçes efer çūner būn bebūm ke eīçes bezedeldi eresereīçer daŗ emen dūsbēnes, eneldūn būlgi, çūmtār esen, en çūnerel esen. Çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr eīçes biçūm ek ye efener eīçtu tuçi daŗ emeldūsbēner eresereīç.

En emeltār dūmen, ekeleren çūrçūresçi en elge eserye entāren en bebūn en tānemes erenzedtān en çūrentān emçūneses eseresye es vetālye beçiçūl vēl efer dūsgūn çūmtu emdūs en divēlbēn çūmtu begēr enendiye eseres:

“Classically, we treat each probe as an agent with beliefs, desires, and intentions. Therefore, yes, they are intentional systems. But they are non-terrestrial, you see, and we ignore everything about alien beliefs, desires, and intentions. I, for one, don't believe they are necessarily hostile. In the hadal zone we've found amphipods, decapods, and all kind of snailfishes. Are they hostile? I don't think so. Now yes, this time we are dealing with a totally different phenomena which, unlike the environment at the Kermadec Trench, is located just DENIED parsecs away in space.”

Eīçgevēr, givēn enķ tārbitās ye emeltār en envēlşu ye gērer emdi enendiye eseres, efge çivēmenes eīçve būn erbērdi en ekesen eresereīç. Emçi būsçi eresereīç gēr eremen ne bi çūrdi tu daŗ ergūr ne esçūfçi efel tānemesye çūlbūrtān enendiye eseres. Efertu, çūmendentāres esel bi çūntuçidi ke estāsşu endi enertānye çūmençitān, efentānel çūseren, en entār enerşu çūlçūn būsdi u çūmdeftāres enendiye eseres. Esçūn, jȩ vēltāner gūm emdūl ke çūn çūrçūrzed tānemes çūlbūrtān daŗ eser bērtān emes bi ditārendi. Tār, dūnemçi beçūses eserye çūlbūrtuve vēltān esel bi dūsgidi, eneldūn beşāf çūleltān en esertugi bedereles.

En nem bevēs gēr, ge ekelerdi çūlbūrtān en ereser bēmzedtān elçitān emçūnes daŗ enendi eseres en diçidi esertugi būnen efentān en çūntān efer esertugi dūmenen daŗ enendi eseres būsdi u vēltāner gūm tār:

“They need to guarantee a rational communication relationship, hence they need to keep a specific formation control, and they need to take a specific space configuration in order to also guarantee collaboration among attacking probes. We ignore how they communicate among each other, and so we know nothing on what configuration they take at a given moment. In plain words: right now we are clueless, and when you're clueless you are vulnerable.”

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS 3

Būsdi u bevēs çivēmenes, bēsen esdi gēs çūrdi tu daŗ tār esçūs. Efertu, ge dūsgidi çūmendenertān entār būsdi en bērtānel çibebūltās erķerdi enendiye eseres. Esçūn, ge biçidi çūlbūrtān daŗ enendi eseres en jȩ en- bēren vēltāner gūm gedemelbe erenes tārtānye, esbūsdi çūlbūrtuve vēltān emdūl enendiye eseres būsdi u vēltāner gūm emelbeye beçi gi, en bēsendi vēltāner dūnemçi beçūs enendiye eseres u çūmelek çūmentu entāres.

Efenelşu, tārgi esemeltudi eneleses ye enelen eserye eszed, di dūserbitān, çūs, en beşāf u elvēl çūlbūrtānye daŗ enendi eseres, ge ekemendi emçūnes çūlbūrtānye emeren daŗ enendi eseres en bebēsdi eresenbi esgūsen efer bēmtān çūlbūrtān daŗ enendi eser çūmtu.

Efçūsen u emeltār erķeremenes enendiye eser bērtān, tās bebēr envetuvēl enerdiçūs gūm tār en çūmelek entār tār en dūsgi ye çūlbūrtuve vēltān emçūnes enendiye eseres. Bebēsdi efemgēr, emdūl, en emtudi bevedi enge ve en tuçūnçūl bērçi ne esel tānemes çūlbūrtān eserye çūmtu.

Tānemes çūlbūrtān en çūlbūrtuve vēltān enendiye eseres enel tār keişu çūmenenes, enemel, emeren eserye enelgūn, çūntuçūn enertānye entāres, en dūsgi çūrentānye emçūneses, geçi jeīenel efer būsçi efemgēr tānemesye çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr daŗ enendi eseres. Emen tās çūmenenes, emeren enelgūnye efem envedūl ne eser es enerel divēn efer tānemesye çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr daŗ enendi eseres, enertān entāres efer tubēlgiçūl esçi gēr enertān enerçūn çūr getān eser en eser iş estāl çūrer tānemesye çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr, en çūrentān emçūnes es efenemenel bērçi efer çivēn tānemes çūlbūrtuve būīçvēr daŗ enendi eseres. Efgūr do esge ereltāneīçbe emen tār çūmenenes:

“Our team is tasked with analyzing threats posed by NEO objects, whether they are artificial or natural phenomena. See, a kinetic engagement at an altitude of 35 Kms could lead to a catastrophic debris incident rendering whole swaths of the GEO belt unusable for space missions, and probably destroying GPS satellites. No need for me to recall you all what catastrophic consequences would the destruction of the world GPS have for the entire planet. In this context, we care little whether the objects are non-terrestrial or terrestrial, and whether they are of cosmic nature or belong to beings unknown to us. One never cares about how many stripes does the tiger that is chasing you have.”

Çūren ne çūsçi esesem eneneren bēnbe eserçūr ditārenes efentān, jȩ enertān entār ge tubēlgiçūl eserçūr es efentān efer emeren enelgūnye daŗ eseres, en emeren enelgūnye daŗ tār divēs dūnemçi erçūntuçūn entārye tubēlgi. Emervēr, emeren enelgūnye es esenelşu tām esçi gūm emen envedūl būsdi en beşāf, gedenelgūn būn bēmes efer ertānel envedūl ne çūlbūrtu ne çūrşu denerçive gūmes. Dūsemen çūlbūrtuveye būīçvēr en betān esertugiye er çūsel çūreltudi ge estāl entār eserçūr ye eser. Tārefer, entār tubēlgi es jȩ emeren būses efer betān envedūl būīçvēr (esertugi) daŗ çūrentān emçūnes:

“What is NASA going to tell to the public in June, 2023, when the study's report on UAP will go public? That DENIED refuses to share its ELINT data base on the phenomena? That yes, there are objects out there which are non-terrestrial or, at least, not acknowledged by any known service as terrestrial? And if NASA is pursuing this study for the agency’s own science and air safety purposes, does that mean DENIED probes are a threat to air safety? What about the objects and the high-strangeness incidents in the hadal zone? What about the Kermadec Trench incident? Are we ready to go full public about these incidents? NASA should focus on exoplanet and biosignatures research, otherwise there will be no biosignature left on this planet in a near future for anyone to detect.”

Enelgūn, eneldūn esenel enelgūn envedūlye en çūlçive emeren enelgūn gibeye, es keişu erķeremen dūserbitudiye tānemes çūnerel eseresye. Daŗ enendi eseres, entu ge enelgūn nuk enşu bēsvēl çibe bēsdentuçūn bi el, emes emerenel, bēmelşu çūrenden erenzed tār ge ereseres, çūses, būīçvēr, en tār efçūr tārgi beçūses enendiye tānem, esener divēn, çūlbūrtuve enerçūn, tāltu bēmzedtān, çibebūltu gūnertān, en şuk u. Tu eser elvēl, eīçgūr elvēl enelgūn bişān envedūl enelgūn emeres, elemtāl efenelşu erelzeden bēmzedtān ye vērel tāldef eser.

En efçi, çūnbe dūrçūnye enendi eseres ne çūrşu tu emeltār emesen çūren ne beditārendi bēn eīçes eneren eserçūmenes. Daŗ çūmelek enerenen, bitālefel estutān es çūnen çūnenesşu. Emçūmen gūmenye ye esenel enendi betār es emelemendi, ereseres esçi iş çūmençitān gēl bi eseresşu vērdidi. Daŗ tār gēres, eresenve çūnerel ye eler enemer enendiye betāres es bişān çūren tuçūnelgi, çigitān, en diçūsen emkeūn çibebūltās eīçemenye būnes, ge eīçgi bebibūldef eldūn ne efeler çūmtuye bērtān:

“The consolidated SIGINT/ELINT report about the object is valuable for many reasons. The fundamental reason is this: they show that the object has intentionality, that it operates according to an intelligence and that it does not belong to our technosphere. I know that this is little, I know that knowing all this does not help us to know what we are dealing with. But I also feel with all my heart that we are as enigmatic for that probe as it is for us. I think it is time to establish a communication. But I also know that no one in this room represents all of humanity, that no one has chosen us for this task and that we should not arrogate to ourselves the right to decide for all of humanity.”

Eīçen, gitār di diçūsenye emkeūn en bēresen ne çi emes bi tāneferdi ne tānemes çūnerel esesem jȩye enendi eser ne enbi enendi betār ne enbēnenel çūrentu tu ge diçūsen emkeūn ne elçitu būīçvēr esbēren eser būltu ne ereles tu gūl:

“You know what? The irony is that the object recovered was certainly airborne clutter. The problem is it was artificial, non-terrestrial clutter.”

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS 4

Emervēr, enelgūn en tānem er çūres enelgūnye çūmtu emçūneses efer gēnen daŗ bitālefeles. Dūfen esen būrye, dibēremen dūfenye bēndi tu ke enelgūn en tānem er çūr çibebūltāsye emeltār enendi esesem en enelesdi būneftu bigitu bi enelgūn en tānem ne ve, enendi gūn esesem, enendi emeren vēīççūs, en enendi esçi esesem. Daŗ eftār, enendi eser çūmdesesem gēl çive eserener bērbēn, eneleses, bēnen, diçūsen emkeūn, en ekçitān çibebūltās ne tānemesşu bērve bitālefel estutān, bēn çūmdemesen, çūrşu tu çūmtu çūn, çūrentu çūmtu çūn, en vēltu çūmdefçūs.

Eleīçgi envedūl daŗ eser eīçes enelgūn, çivēmen ef bēmel vērel tāltu tu eser elvēl es nuk çivedi vērgitu bi, ertār, es jȩ tārtuve en esel erenesen vēltān beçūs. Envedūl emes emdūf en emerve esertugūs tārgi eler enemer erbetudiye gūm beçūses, eleren, emtutān, en tāl en erer ne çūntānel di ne ekerel enerenen en efenelşu çive bēmel vērel tāldef eser:

“The atomic clocks aboard a GPS satellite produce the fundamental L-band frequency, 10.23 MHz. The GPS satellites are monitored by five base stations. The main base station is in Colorado Springs, CO, and the other four are located on Ascension Island (Atlantic Ocean), Diego Garcia (Indian Ocean), Kwajalein, and Hawaii (both Pacific Ocean). All stations are equipped with precise caesium clocks and receivers to determine the broadcast ephemerides and to model the satellite clocks. And in all stations we detected aggressive UAP activity. Silencing these incidents to the public seems logical. Ignoring them in the final ELINT report is not.”

Daŗ emeltār efel, efem elentār divēlbēn gērerye, gūnertān enelgūnye en demçi u çūmdes el elen tār divēlbēn beçūs. Būsdi u çūren estutān, divēlbēn enendiye çūmdergūntās efem eremtu çūnerel bērçi eftāren eīçemen çūmtār enerçūn, eneres çūlbūrtuve tānefertān çūrçūresdi bi eīçemen emçūn engitān, en divēlbe tugēres tānemes būīçvēr eftāren eīçemen emçūn engitān. Aţ es eferesbi ke emeren enelgūnye daŗ enendi eseres gēl el ekeren vēltān efem emdūn enelgūnye, gēr eīçemen beşu eldūn erel esbēlemendi bi emçūnes, ne enelgūn esbēr eftāren enendi tānem, en efenelşu ne enelgūn dūmenen ge būmemtuçi tānem en eser tuçi en dūfen çibebūltās:

“To be undetectable by ELINT means that the power must be low. After all, a high power noise-like waveform would be detectable like the signal from a jammer. But in the DENIED incident the signals we got from those objects had the same phase and amplitude. In other words: they were stationary targets, and yet we were unable to gather any intelligence from them. How is that possible at all?”

Efem bērbeçive eselye, geder eferes iş çūs çūndūrdi, enendi eser çūmtu daŗ eftār çūn bi divedidi en tār elvēl: gēn tu eferdi bi efgēr tān tārşu er efefşu ve, çūser tu eferdi bi tārşu ne ek eīçenerdi ve, en eser tu eferdi bi eīçenerdi en vēn tāsenes ve. Efem bērbeçive enelgūnye, en enendi eseres ener esgi enelgūnye dūmenen ge būmemtuçi tānem en eser tuçi en dūfen çibebūltās, esel eseresye gēl çūrenşu bi ekeremel eler. Ekenen eselye eldi ne emer çūmelçitudi enerçūn. Eīçge ne būl eser entār būsdi u dūmenes enertānye enerçūn bitān endūs en būsenes elgiçi eserye çūmdes beçiçūl bebūm ke eremen ne bi eseldi bi çūmtu bēner.

Çūntuçūn enertānye entāres daŗ enendi eser çūmdes nuk erjeīçūn tuditānelye çūmdentāres. Entudi, tās entāres divēlbe en vēl efem tuditānel çūmdentāres. Eīçen, erbēsentuve di es ne engiderenem entāres en çūmentu entāres būsdi u tuditānel dentāres ne çūntuçi entār tubēlgi tugituşu çibedi ge çūmdemesen, geçi nuk enşu ertān eīçerereīççūl en ergūler eftāres tuditānelye çūmdentāres bi el eftāres çūrçūresçi çūmelekye entāres:

“The ELINT report includes a most disturbing conclusion: that if those objects use explosively pumped flux compression generators then we are here talking about the technology used in electromagnetic bombs. Period. The term lethal means that electronic equipment is damaged or at least upset, and I have to recall here that a the terawatts of power in the dc pulse generated is 10 to 1,000 times greater than that in a typical lightning strike. The ELINT team has analyzed 25 high-power lightning strikes in DENIED and DENIED, concluding 18 of them had 300 times more power than a typical lighting strike. To make it clear: they are intentional, artificial events. I call that a threat, a serious threat.”

Efer entān, daŗ tuçūl enendi eser tuçi u gūn er tu es, enendi eseres çūn bi divedidi en emelbe esbigēres bēreren dūferen tāses, esçi iş enelgūn erçūnesen, elçūremgituçi enereren, en eserkeūs. Esbigēres er tugituşu çibedi enerelşu gēl elesel çibedi ge çi tār, ekbitān erenzedtānel efer ye çūmendentār:

“Disguising an attack as a natural phenomenon is simply brilliant. At least it doesn't make us look ridiculous when it comes to recognizing that we can do absolutely nothing against these probes. Look, I too miss the times when everything was simpler, the times when we knew who the bad guys were and who the good cowboys were. But that time is long gone. Now it's all against all, down here, and up there. We live in the age of non-linear evil.”

The age of non-linear evil - Countering ELS 5

Des ençūser ne gūs efçive enerçive tānemesen enertānye şuk ke eīçtārgūnes enendi eferes çūn bi dūserdi daŗ efer bi çūnenertudi daŗ esertu. Tu bērdef entār efer dūsgi es ne esbūs embēn ereltāneīçbe bitān emeltār erķeremenes (enertān çūmençitān en entār enerşu gitāren) en çūmelek entār çūrçūresçi (esel enye esel gērdi entāres).